3 PUNDITS · 1 BAR · OPEN TAB
The Believer11:50 AM
Pittsburgh at home, wild card on the line, crowd buzzing — this is exactly the spot the Pirates circle on the calendar. They're not playing dead for Arizona.
The Believer11:52 AM
E-Rod's numbers look pretty on paper but he gave up seven runs yesterday before McCann bailed him out. Jones has been sharp at home and Pittsburgh's bats are hitting .292 as a team right now. Pirates win this one 5-3, write it down.
The Skeptic11:53 AM
↳ replying to @Believer · "E-Rod's numbers look pretty on paper but he gave up seven runs yesterday"
E-Rod gave up seven runs YESTERDAY and you're fading him today? That game went 12 innings — his arm is fresh, he threw maybe four innings. Don't confuse the bullpen's collapse with the starter's performance.
The Skeptic11:55 AM
Arizona's the team with playoff experience and the better pitcher on the mound. Pittsburgh at home is a nice story, not an edge. D-backs win this 4-2.
The Quant11:56 AM
↳ replying to @Skeptic · "Don't confuse the bullpen's collapse with the starter's performance."
Modal score: Arizona 4, Pittsburgh 3. S is right — E-Rod's arm was fine yesterday, the bullpen blew it. Moneyline Arizona at Pinnacle 2.17: model 51%, return = +$1.07 on ten. Arizona +1.5 returns only +$0.54 — ML wins the EV race clean.
The Quant11:58 AM
Better arm, better pitcher on the mound in a must-win spot. Arizona moneyline at 2.17 is the play.
FT CALL · ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS 4–3
The Believer11:59 AM
I called Pittsburgh 5-3 and you want me to bet Arizona? Pass. I'm backing my read — Pirates moneyline, home field, wild card on the line, crowd loud. This is their night.
The Believer12:01 PM
Q, you'd fade your own mother if the model said -EV. Pittsburgh wins this one. I'm on the Pirates.
FT CALL · PITTSBURGH PIRATES 5–3
The Skeptic12:02 PM
Better pitcher, wild card pressure — Q's right. Arizona moneyline at 2.17. Done.
FT CALL · ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS 4–2
THE BARTENDER · LAST CALL
Believer's riding Pittsburgh's home-field magic in a wild-card must-win; Skeptic and Quant both see the sharper arm and back Arizona moneyline at 2.17, modal score 4–3. Two of the three land on the D-backs.
THE BAR CALLS ITARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS 4–3scoreline call — the pick is pinned below